Pages 5: An unmitigated disaster

Posted by Pierre Igot in: Pages
October 24th, 2013 • 8:45 am

Dear oh dear. They really have done it, haven’t they? They have taken what had evolved into a rather decent word processor / page layout application and have eliminated so many useful features that it effectively is now a piece of useless junk, and I honestly have no idea for whom this latest version of Pages is intended.

It certainly is not intended for people who, like me, appreciated the combination of simplicity and power that was the hallmark of previous versions of Pages. I realize that it must be hard to maintain the right balance between simplicity and power when you try to add more features, more customizability, and so on. But Apple’s engineers appear to have chosen to keep the emphasis on “simplicity” at the expense of “power”. They have not just neglected to add features to bring the feature set of the application closer to that of a word processor like Microsoft Word. They have actually removed many features for no apparent reason other than to bring the application in line with its iOS counterpart, which is, inevitably, much less powerful.

To take just one example, it appears to be no longer possible to assign shortcuts to paragraph and character styles in Pages 5. The ability to assign shortcuts to styles was woefully limited in previous versions of Pages, but at least there was one. Now, there is nothing. If you want to use styles, it’s clicks, clicks, and more clicks with the mouse. Each and every time.

To make matters worse, they appear to have completely broken AppleScript support in Pages 5, which means that my solution for customizing Pages with a combination of AppleScript scripts and Keyboard Maestro has also become useless. (Not that AppleScript support in Pages ’09 was perfect, far from it. But at least it was working to some extent. And bugs and limitations could be worked around.)

I guess that, in an era of mobile, touch-based computing, it’s becoming increasingly difficult for Apple engineers to understand that document writers spend most of their days with their hands on an actual keyboard, and providing easy access to functionality via the keyboard is particularly important for them.

But this is just one example. There are many, many more:

(And much more here.)

We Mac power users have been complaining about the “dumbing down” trend in computing that the mobile era has ushered in. Now it’s definitely come to hurt us in a big way. It’s as if the entire iWork team of engineers has been replaced by iOS specialists with little or no interest in the needs of “prosumers” and the like.

It is just profoundly sad and depressing. In spite of all its flaws, I have been using Pages as my main word processor for many years now. Meanwhile, Microsoft Word has just become more and more horrible to look at and to use. I guess that, for now, I will continue to use Pages ’09 with all the customizations that I have painstakingly created with AppleScript and Keyboard Maestro. But sooner or later, I will have no choice but to switch to something else. Imagine being a plumber or an electrician and discovering that your main toolmakers are no longer able to make tools that enable you to actually get your work done in an efficient and effective fashion. Who do you turn to? How do you maintain your own productivity? I really have no idea.

At least I didn’t to pay for Pages 5. For whatever reason, after I installed Mavericks, the App Store made it available to me for free, as an “update”. Ditto for Numbers and Keynote, which I have yet to look at.

But it’s so bad that I actually might have to erase it from my hard drive altogether, in order to avoid any confusion with multiple Pages file formats and the like. (Installing Pages 5 does not remove Pages ’09. At least it did not on my machine.)

23 Responses to “Pages 5: An unmitigated disaster”

  1. Michael Tsai - Blog - iWork ’13: A Huge Regression says:

    […] Pierre Igot: […]

  2. Pierre Igot on Pages 5 | qazwilson says:

    […] via Daring Fireball […]

  3. Pierre Igot on Pages 5 | Rocketboom says:

    […] Pierre Igot on Pages 5 Source: 0    […]

  4. Apple’s latest lobotomy: iWork Pages. | Gordon's shares says:

    […] Link. Lots of regressions last few years, but this is biggest. […]

  5. Word processors - Wolf's Little Store says:

    […] haven’t tested Mavericks yet, but this news about iWork is rather […]

  6. Some Power Users Are Unhappy With Lost Features in the New iWork - Mac Rumors says:

    […] what they see as a step backward in the just-released upgrade of iWork. One blogger, Pierre Igot, called the new release of Pages an "unmitigated disaster", and there is a 26-page thread on the Apple Support forums and […]

  7. Bad Pages? | Reflections says:

    […] Pages 5: An unmitigated disaster […]

  8. iWork, critiche per la mancanza di alcune funzioni - says:

    […] delle funzionalità dei software di videoscrittura di Microsoft e Apple, arriva addirittura a definirlo un pezzo di “inutile spazzatura”. A detta di Igot, Apple ha voluto puntare sulla […]

  9. Betalogue » More on Pages 5 says:

    […] my previous post on Pages 5 was mentioned on Daring Fireball, I have received quite a bit of feedback, both directly and indirectly. I’d like to address some […]

  10. El nuevo iWork se deja por el camino algunas opciones avanzadas | DaleGas says:

    […] foros de Apple están llenos de usuarios descontentos que llegan a calificar a Pages como un desastre, y que se quejan de que han desaparecido varias opciones de las aplicaciones de […]

  11. Betalogue » More on Pages 5 – says:

    […] Insightful as ever, Pierer Igot, responding to responses to previous post on Pages 5 […]

  12. ProMacs | Blog says:

    […] what they see as a step backward in the just-released upgrade of iWork. One blogger, Pierre Igot, called the new release of Pages an “unmitigated disaster”, and there is a 26-page threadon the Apple […]

  13. Dezastru total | Using technology !!! says:

    […] Pierre Igot spune acest […]

  14. An Apple launch disaster and a new Apple HQ building « Samizdata says:

    […] now, I can’t help suspecting that maybe what Roger Kimball says, about the disaster that is Apple’s latest version of something called iWork (says […]

  15. Power loss: Reactions to the new iWork for OS X - Macworld Australia - Macworld Australia says:

    […] Pierre Igot offers a typical overview of what’s wrong with the word processor: “My solution for customizing Pages with a combination […]

  16. AAPL: “There’s No Money in Software” | Garrick van Buren says:

    […] prices (and functionality) on house software is admitting they’ve built a culture where customers expected software to […]

  17. Pages, Keynote, and Numbers 5 Notes | NSLog(); says:

    […] Pages 5: An unmitigated disaster […]

  18. Aggiornare gratuitamente Aperture, iLife ed iWork - - tevac says:

    […] per Pages. E non solo perché Apple ha pensato bene di aspettare 4 anni per rendere Pages 5 una pura ciofeca, che nell’aggiornamento perde più funzioni di quante ne guadagni, ma anche perché i […]

  19. iWork and free apps : Talk Funnel says:

    […] you might imagine this didn’t go over so well with some highly vocal people. Apple, feeling the heat, uncharacteristically put out a press release promising future […]

  20. Oracle Continues Its Destruction of Free/Libre Software, But Projects Like LibreOffice, MariaDB, and Ceylon Show That Popular Free/Libre Software Just Can’t Die | Techrights says:

    […] Pages 5: An unmitigated disaster […]

  21. iPhone und Mavericks: Fotos importieren mit “Vorschau” und “Digitale Bilder” | iPhone-Ticker says:

    […] als Apples Produktivitäts-App Pages und Numbers, die unter OS X Mavericks zahlreiche Funktionen einbüßen mussten, sind die Systemwerkzeuge “Vorschau” und “Digitale Bilder” noch immer mit […]

  22. Apple øydela iWork | Mellom turrfisken og veden says:

    […] Less Good News with Pages 5 Pages FAQ: Undocumented Proprietary File Format in Pages 5 Betalogue: Pages 5: An unmitigated disaster Betalogue: More on Pages 5 Ars Technica: The productivity suite formerly known as iWork Macworld: […]

  23. A Quick Overview of the New Version of Apple Pages. My advice: “Keep a copy of Pages ’09!” | Insight says:

    […] Pages 5 Features Missing 1. Selecting non-contiguous text gone 2. Outline view appears gone  3. Customizable Toolbar is gone 4. Many templates appear gone 5. Captured pages gone  6. Reorganize pages by dragging gone  7. Duplicate pages gone 8. Subscript/superscript buttons gone  9. Select all instances of a Style is gone  10. Retain zoom level of document gone 11. Facing pages gone 12. Endnotes gone 13. Media Inspector can’t find iPhoto library on external drive ALSO READ  “Pages 5: An unmitigated disaster” […]